So it’s finally here. After nearly eight years, and more than four hundred nominee profiles, it’s time to close the final chapter on the Vetting Room. When I first started the Vetting Room eight years ago, I wrote my hopes that this blog would be a way to “inform the general public about candidates for the federal bench.” I think we’ve succeeded in doing that. I also hoped that, by providing “disinterested” commentary (in the sense that we’re not advocating for or against individual nominees), the Vetting Room could be a part of de-escalating confirmation tensions and supporting an apolitical judiciary.
Reflecting back, there is much to be proud of. I never expected that a small legal blog started by a nobody with some assistance from his friends and associates would become one of the most widely searched resources on judicial nominees. Furthermore, I’ve received messages of praise and support from prominent liberals and conservatives who have praised the tone and content of our write-ups. Similarly, I’ve fielded angry messages and comments both from folks convinced that we’re secretly suppressing unfavorable information on nominees and from those accusing us of writing hit pieces, in one case, addressing a single article. Needless to say, we must be doing something right.
I’m also thankful for all the support we’ve gotten, not just from the amazing attorneys who wrote for us, but also from attorneys and law students who helped with research, and from fellow legal bloggers and lawyers who shared, retweeted and commented on our posts. I would note that Howard Bashman of How Appealing has been particularly generous with sharing our write-ups and with his support.
Given all this, one might wonder why the Vetting Room is shuttering. Especially with an incoming Administration that is likely to push to reshape the judiciary in a more conservative direction, and likely to be the source of dozens, if not hundreds, of posts. Well, see, that’s the thing.
Writing and managing a legal blog is not cost-less. Several hours of research, wordsmithing, and analysis go into each post, not just in how to frame each nominee’s background, but also in determining what information should or should not be included. Time spent here is time not spent with my family, or pursuing other passions and interests. Having kept up with the blog through four years of a Republican President and four years of a Democratic President, now seems like the right time to move on.
The Vetting Room is not being taken down, and the posts that are here will stay on (at least for the near future). As time dictates, additional posts detailing the history of the judiciary (some of my favorite writing but ones I’ve had trouble keeping up with) may be added.
This is not to say that it is time to disengage from judicial nominations entirely. Our founding fathers intended for the confirmation process to include public review and input. In the end, all Americans have an interest in having a Judiciary that decides based on the rule of law, rather than ideology or partisanship. And I expect that vigilance in the process will not cease.
Perhaps, if other interested attorneys come forward who would want to carry the mantle for an apolitical judiciary, the Vetting Room may revive as such. Until then, I thank all the readers this blog has maintained for their support and encouragement, and hope that, in our own way, we’ve had a positive impact on the judicial nomination discourse.
I think Manchin is just a true believer in bipartisanship. That’s just who he is. He took a small handful of partisan votes during his last term (ARP, Kevin Ritz, Lucy Koh, Jennifer Sung, a few others) but for the most part he was about consensus.
Sinema I think wrongly calculated that there would be a big red wave in 2022 and she could claim to be the inheritor of McCains legacy in Arizona. Instead, Mark Kelly performed better than she did and she ruined all the goodwill she had with voters. Unable to win in 2024, I believe she sold out to lobbyists and was influenced to stop voting for judges. Which is strange, because she recommended some very progressive judges for Arizona in her time as a Senator. But she was chasing money and influence, I guess.
Those two winning in 2018 made the Biden agenda possible, so I won’t fully trash them. But I think their legacy would have been much better (and Sinema would still be a senator) had they simply voted along with the party consensus through the end of 2024.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Joe, I wholeheartedly agree
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did anyone watch the nominations hearing this morning? I’m curious to see how folks are answering the “who won the 2020 election” question now.
I did read that Ballou, Bennett, Coker, and Rearden were all voted out of committee as well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
@Dequan
100% agree on offering the GOP the same deal on confirming district judges but I have a terrible feeling they don’t have the guts to actually slow down and stop the senate.
LikeLiked by 2 people
We are down at least one democrat for votes in lameduck with Senator Murphy having a stroke and now rehabilitation for several weeks…..
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fetterman also cannot be relied upon to consistently oppose GOP nominations.
However, on the opposite side, McConnell is a vegetable, Tuberville and Blackburn are preparing to be governors, and 11 others are all leaving the senate at the end of the year. Additionally, Husted will be out of office after December 15 as well.
Democrats would be wise to twist the knife as much as possible and make those confirmations TOUGH. At the very least, they should draw a line at those nominees who are having their hearings rushed ahead.
LikeLiked by 2 people
HUGE news!!!
Trump has withdrawn Lee Rudofsky for the 8th & replaced him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland. This goes back to the reports both Arkansas senators wanted him to be the nominee the entire time. This is HUGE with the date being November 10th of a lame duck session.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Does anyone know why this happened?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The article we discussed last weeks stated Bozeman & Cotton wanted Hiland all along. I guess Trump through the could run rough shot over them. Apparently they were withholding support for Rudofsky & had enough votes to block him. I’m sure Trump giving Cotton’s cell number out over the whole Day Lights Savings issue didn’t help. Neither did the election results 7 days ago.
If this seat does not get filled before January 3rd, this may be the biggest non “deal” circuit court blunder I’ve seen since Obama’s Georgia deal. And at least then blue slips were still in play.
LikeLiked by 2 people
@Dequan, I’m hoping this will mean there won’t be enough time to confirm him but I’m not going to celebrate.
There’s no chance this guy is going to be any better on most issues then Lee Rudofsky, I’m just hoping the clock can be dragged out and he won’t get seated at all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The only way Hiland can be confirmed before the new congress is if Grassley discards the 28 day waiting period for a hearing. And if he does that, Dems better not bring it back when they are in charge.
LikeLike
There are a lot of pissed off Republicans on Twitter right now, as Hiland seems like a far less conservative option than Rudofsky. Still a conservative no doubt, but more in the likes of the “classic conservative” G.W. Bush wing of the 8th Circ. (Colloton, Smith, Gruender) as opposed to the far right folks that Trump has nominated. At least that’s what I can gather. There was also a recent National Review article this past summer about this as well:
https://www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/eighth-circuit-considerations/
As to the timing, I see no reason why Hiland doesn’t get the last hearing out of the station in early December (along with other recently announced district court nominees), and then a push to confirm him by year-end. Never underestimate Republican’s ability to leave no nominee behind. All things considered, Butler to the 5th and Hiland to the 8th – the nominees could have been a lot worse…
LikeLiked by 2 people
The outgoing, temp. appointed senator from OK is apparently blocking Zach West. What an odd week this has been… Thune just filed cloture on the two circuit judges and one district court that were pending.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Kevin Hern gets in on Nov. 30 so this is a moot point. I think Alan Armstrong, who wanted to remain in the Senate until January 3rd, is doing this because he’s mad that the Oklahoma Secretary of State sided with Hern on the swearing-in date.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I will say this, yes Manchin and Sinema played ball most of the time but I still can’t forgive what they did at the end.
Two circuit court flips that shouldn’t have happened did while another qualified nominee was denied a seat and for what?
Funny how Manchin/Sinema never demanded Republicans play nice.
As to the nominees who will likely be confirmed, not a surprise on a couple of the circuit court nominees, they’ve been waiting since July and unlike Democrats, there won’t be any Manchin/Sinema pulling moves.
A couple of the other nominees though..who knows?
Even though they will be rushing to beat the clock, one can only guess how many will stick around at the end.
Finally, it’s not a surprise some of the few Reagan/George Sr judges left on the bench haven’t retired.
Not only can some of them live for another ten years like Edith Jones but they’ve been wanting right wing courts all their life, why give up that power now?
LikeLiked by 3 people
Honestly, I’m curious how Trump is going to handle all of the nominations in split-senate state delegations. Before, he had a senate majority to act as a cushion against any major dem pushback. All he had to do was come to an agreement with whatever
cuckdem senator had blue slip power over the nominee, and once the 1 out of 3/4 garbage deal was agreed upon, 3 Fedsoc hacks were confirmed to the district court level. With a dem senate majority, will Trump even bother nominating moderate conservatives/centrists in an attempt to get them past the SJC and full senate?? Will a ML Schumer (plz dear God no) or a ML Van Hollen (plz dear God yes) put a blanket hold on all judicial nominees like McConnell did to Obama 10+ years ago?I think Trump’s ego and inability to concede defeat will lead to it being easier for whoever is in charge of the senate and SJC to just vote down all of his hack judicial nominees. Schumer/Van Hollen can just not schedule full floor votes in general even if they get through the committee, or they can let the nominations die in the committee organically.
Either way, I’m curious how things pan out. Eagerly awaiting a few Bush/Trump 1 judges to assume senior status and realizing that there will be no successor for 2+ years. And/or the older and more stubborn Reagan/H.W./Bush Jr./Obama judges to leave feet first or assume senior status at the wrong time. Overall, I need the 2029 Dem President to walk into the oval office with a big present of 75 vacancies on the DC level, 10 on the CCA level, and hopefully 1 unfilled SCOTUS seat.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Also, an underrated question for fine folks here. Which senators do you think will end up with spots on the SJC??
I remember Ossoff being taken off in 2025 when the GOP took over the senate, and he didn’t seem to upset about it. It probably harkens back to someone on here pointing out that the issue of the judiciary isn’t as important and crucial to Dems as it is to the GOP. That’s why you have a random backbencher senator like Dan Sullivan giving a floor speech about the importance of future 9th circuit judges adhering to Alaskan principles and traditions when deciding cases involving Alaskan legal cases prior to confirmation. And, if my memory is correct, wasn’t there a random rumor or article about Sullivan wanting a private meeting with every 9th circuit nominee?? LMAOOOOO. I can’t wait till that pompous prick is gone in a little under 2 months.
To just give my overall prediction, I think it’ll end up being like this:
Whitehouse (SJC Chairman), Coons, Blumenthal, Hirono, Booker, Padilla, Welch, Schiff, Talarico, Colom, Cooper, Stratton
I basically just predict that Ossoff will probably run for president in 2028, and won’t have time to accurately question whichever whackjob nominees Trump puts forward, and they won’t waste a spot for him if he’s not really interested. Instead, I think they welcome 4 new members from the incoming freshman class. Cooper, Stratton, and Colom all have law degrees and an extensive legal background which would play very well in SJC hearings for judicial nominees and oversight of various industries/companies. Talarico is not a lawyer, but I think they’d be hard pressed NOT to keep the entire Texas senate delegation on the committee as a giant middle finger to Cruz. Plus, Texas is a big ass state, you want Talarico there so he can get his feet wet in federal judicial confirmation battles. Hopefully he can come up with his own process of vetting potential candidates.
And forgive me, but I have to lib out for a minute…. Can y’all believe the glorious potential sweet sweet irony of the same blue slip that was withheld from Scott Colom 3 years ago, being placed into the very hands of future Sen. Scott Colom for him to decide who gets to be on ANY district court seat in Mississippi?!?!?!? Like, c’mon, that’s epic levels of karma.
(Not to mention that Wicker and Colom can probably get along very well and agree on centrist judges faster than racist meemaw Hyde-Smith).
Would love to hear any thoughts on who might or might not be added to the committee.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are correct, Sullivan demanded Biden let him meet with ALL 9th Circuit nominees. He had the nerve to say he might have voted for some had he been allowed to meet with them. At least we know after he loses the race against Pelota he can find work as a stand up comedian because that was hilarious… Haaaaaa
Senator Ossoff has repeatedly said he won’t be running for president in 2028. I truly hope he does the same thing Governor Clinton & Senator Obama did & flip flops on that statement. Ossoff has the potential to be our generations JFK or Bobby Kennedy (Had he lived).
Your prediction of four freshman Democrat senators on the SJC is possible. Senior senators have passed on previous vacancies so it’s very plausible they will pass on the committee again. I think Colom is a lock. I have to admit Stratton is the freshman senator I know the least about since her victory was never in doubt but I could see her added. I could see Cooper as well. I’m not so sure about Talarico. I would put Andrews higher on my list as a possibility than him. Plus we know the history of her seat on the SJC.
And I remember when I first suggested right here on this blog that Colom should run against Hyde-Smith after she blocked his nomination, a few people on here called me crazy. When the Jackson batch drops tomorrow it will feel like sweet vindication to see Colom with an insurmountable lead. I can’t think of a more gratifying senate win since I first got into politics in 2001. Thank you Mississippi
LikeLiked by 2 people
I actually went through and thought through each incoming dem senator and decided which one made the most sense to me. Would it surprise me if Sen.-elect Turek or Peltola ended up on the SJC?? Absolutely not. I just need someone to be present for all committee meetings and to be ready to rubberstamp dem nominees when the time comes. Honestly, I googled which of the incoming senators on the dem side have law degrees, and only 3 of them (Cooper, Stratton, and Colom) do. So, I just thought it would be prudent to put them on the one committee with legal jurisdiction over the DOJ and judiciary.
I’m sure Sen.-elect Annie Andrews can be a rubberstamp on the SJC, but it would be a waste of her talents tbh. I want her on the HELP committee chaired by Bernie, and having fellow Sen.-elect & Med School graduate El-Sayed tag team RFK Jr. and all over healthcare company executives.
I think Stratton is the right kind of no nonsense dem senator to sit on the committee and give judicial nominees HELL.
And to you my good sir, I raise a long-distance glass to you for calling your shot years in the future. I was probably one of those people that mocked you or openly dismissed your idea. In my defense, NO ONE would ever think a senate seat in deep-red Mississippi would be in play 3 years later. But you were one of the only ones with the foresight, so I will make the crow-eating and humble pie servings be as loud as the lack of faith and disrespect. You’ve earned it sir!
Also, good riddance to that bozo Dan Sullivan. Maybe he can work as a clerk to a few 9th circuit judges in his spare time. Or run for Governor of Alaska and fill the state courts with as many hacks as he’d like.
Ditto on the Ossoff take, I think he would be great as POTUS, he just needs to build the momentum, and we can be well on our way to another landslide election.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think Ossoff would be a great candidate. Young, charismatic, and he can be a pragmatist while still selling himself as a progressive. He is also an extremely skilled debater. He’s got a great team behind him too.
Frankly Warnock would be a strong contender for the same reason. Georgia did very well picking those two in 2020.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dawson, I agree. Justice indeed for Scott Colom.
I do think he and Wicker may be able to work together some. Would certainly prefer that pair to a hypothetical Colom/CHS one
LikeLiked by 1 person
Remember Senator Wicker returned his blue slip for Colom. They should be able to work together just fine. The sad part is Trump has filled a substantial number of judicial vacancies in the state so I’m not so sure how many will need to get filled over the next 6 years. Hopefully Colom will be reelected so then we can see some vacancies.
LikeLike
I can’t believe the Texas Supreme Court could flip to blue within just one year
Aside from the 4 flips this year, one of the more moderate Republican judges, Justice Debra Lehrmann is thinking of retiring early just after Gina Hinojosa takes office
For the sake of Texas, I hope she does follow through with this. God, imagine the SCOTX flipping blue before even North Carolina and Ohio
Blue wave could swamp Texas Supreme Court if GOP justice bails: report – Raw Story
LikeLiked by 2 people
So what does everyone think Senate Democrats will do regarding circuit court nominees? I HOPE they allow few, if any to get confirmed…There needs to be payback for what McConnell did in 2015-16. And I can’t see Trump even attempting to work with Democrats so I thinks best thing to do is let the vacancies pile up
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hope they allow ZERO. Since Trump has become president, Republicans have eliminated the filibuster for Supreme Court nominees, eliminate blue slips for circuit court nominees, changed the rules so they can confirm multiple non judicial nominees at the same time (So they have more time to confirm judges), after blocking President Obama’s SCOTUS nominee for 11 months because it was an election year, they rushed to confirm a SCOTUS nominee after voting had begun in a presidential election just 4 years later, gave judicial nominees a hearing without the standard 28 day waiting period and now they have scheduled multiple SJC hearings back to back weeks during a lame duck session after they lost from sea to shinning sea.
Democrats should shut down judicial confirmations for 2 years. Trump doesn’t need any more picks & they are under no obligation to play nice with all the things I mentioned above. They need to spend the next 2 years getting this country back on track as well as investigating the corruption of this administration. If Trump wants to cut a deal in some blue & purple states that’s worth confirming the nominees such as a 1 for 1 deal then that’s fine. Other than that, Republicans did what they wanted & broke norms when they had power so Democrats should respond in kind now that they have power.
LikeLike
@ Dequan I’m going to assume Democrats win in Alaska & Mississippi. Based on the current totals, it sure looks like it is when, not if, Peltola, and Colom are declared the winners. Can you imagine Senate Majority Leader Schumer (assuming it’s him) has 56 members and DOES NOT have to worry about the likes of a Manchin and Sinema.. Any Trump nominee would need 6 Democratic senators to get confirmed.. And I cannot imagine Trump and senate Democrats being able to work on nominees in any way shape or form. Yeah, I think the best outcome is whatever business is conducted in the Senate Judiciary Committee the next 2 years, it does not involve any judicial nominations. Not even for the Court of International Trade either.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well I wouldn’t say Trump can’t negotiate with Democrats on judges at all. In Trump 1.0 we got several Democrats in states like Pennsylvania, Michigan & New York. We even got Democrats without any Republicans in exchange in states like Rhode Island. I think we will see some deals but not many.
LikeLike
@Dequan, when will we know if Dems are playing hardball with judicial votes or just letting Republicans confirm as many as they can as fast as they can?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think by the Summer recess we will know for sure
LikeLike
Sorry, I should’ve clarified.
I mean for this lame duck session regarding if Dems give GOP a deal for districts but not circuit confirmations or if they let them confirm as many as they can.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Democrats should make a deal where they leave the 8th circuit seat open for this year and agree to confirm Hiland next year in exchange for a moderate liberal judge on a circuit court seat that opens in 2027. Any deal should also prevent the filling of any vacancy that was not publicly known on Election Day.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apparently conservatives are unhappy that Butler and Hiland are not very conservative. And Tillis and Cornyn are willing to buck the White House and speak up on behalf of other Republican senators not on the judiciary committee. Should be an interesting lame duck session.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Scott Colom has won in MS.
Holy cow!!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Put it bluntly, it’s not just the Trump era as to why Democrats shouldn’t play nice.
Once Republicans took control of the Senate in 1994 under Bill Clinton, Orrin Hatch engaged in judicial obstruction to the point William Rehnquist of all people had to tell him to knock it off but even so, many Circuit court seats were left open and until Trump, George W inherited the largest amount of judicial vacancies, by design.
And of course, he insisted the blue slip rule for circuit court nominees be honored, something he changed his mind on under George W.
Patrick Leahy pretended that didn’t happen and played nice AND let George W get right wing hacks after 06.
We know what happened after that.
That can’t be allowed to happen again.
Durbin for all his flaws ditched the blue slip rule for circuit court nominees for good.
Democrats need to do that and keep other rules Republicans ditched out as well.
The time for playing nice is over.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I have a theory about the Arkansas vacancies. One is that the Senators didn’t want to leave a vacant District Judgeship with a Democrat-controlled Senate. Also, the Arkansas GOP has someone specific in mind to put on the state Supreme Court.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I thought of that but this now puts the 8th seat itself in jeopardy
LikeLike
@Dequan, I agree.
We saw a flip on the 7th and 1st because even McConnell couldn’t arrange hearings/nominees fast enough for vacancies that late.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Judge Richard Posner has died
LikeLiked by 1 person
Tomorrow the U.S. Senate will vote on Justice Greg Cook to serve on Alabama District Court.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Richard Posner was a legal giant. Reagan appointed many of those to his credit. May he rest in peace…
Although Justice Greg Cook is hard core MAGA, with his age I think he’s still the best we could hope for from Alabama. Hopefully with Democrats now taking the South seriously, we can get a credible challenger for the US senate there over the next few elections to get at least one Democrat blue slip in play there.
LikeLike
RIP Richard Posner. One of the last old guard Republicans willing to go against his party.
Regarding seats in Mississippi that might utilize Colom’s blue slip, I’d be watching to see if Debra Brown or Carlton Reeves (senior eligible in 2028 and 2029 respectively) go senior if a Democrat is president. Both are African-American and they are the only two Dem appointees on Mississippi district courts, so they might decide it’s their chance with a Dem president and Sen. Colom. Additionally, 79-year old Reagan appointee Henry Wingate has not gone senior, though he seems to be living on elven time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Richard Posner was a former Brennan clerk just like Michael McConnell.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Congrats to Senator Colom!!! I absolutely want him on the Judiciary Committee. Stratton too. Of the remaining 8 Judiciary Committee Dems, only 1 (Mazie Hirono) is a woman, so the Democrats definitely need at least 1 new woman, and I think Stratton would be the best fit. Then choose between Cooper, Talarico, and whoever else might be interested in a spot on Judiciary.
With a presumed 56 seats, I think Democrats get a 12-9 majority on the Judiciary Committee, meaning 4 new Dems on the committee. Stratton, Talarico, & Cooper would effectively be replacing Durbin, Cornyn, & Tillis, and I guess Colom replaces Klobuchar (Graham seat gets dissolved under this scenario). GOP doesn’t need to kick anyone and they can still add 1 member to replace Blackburn.
LikeLiked by 3 people
It seems to me that Judiciary Committee is in the wheelhouse of Colom and Cooper. It’s possible that there are sitting senators who could move to the Judiciary Committee.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder how Roy Cooper will be on judicial nominations? His reputation is moderate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
By a vote of 49-27, the Senate confirmed the nomination of Gregory Carl Cook to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Alabama.
So much for playing hard ball, half the democratic caucus didn’t even show up. Every easy confirmation the GOP makes now i one less point of leverage Sems have in December.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Democrats are in Denver for a conference to map out their agenda for the majority. I’m not sure why they didn’t schedule this on the weekend instead of during the week when they know there would be votes taken…smh
LikeLike
The Denver conference is today. Both Schumer and Van Hollen showed up to vote yesterday, so I don’t think we can attribute absences to this conference.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh I didn’t say that it was a GOOD reason, just saying that’s probably the reason. Many senators probably wanted to get across country a day earlier. But again I am in no means saying it’s a GOOD reason.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think originally the senate was supposed to be in recess for Veterans Day, but Thune kept them in session an extra two days. Seems dumb to leave town early after weeks off.
My hope is they come back next week with a better plan. Senate Dems need to play much tougher, at the very least with the nominees that haven’t had a hearing and are being rushed into one. Grassley ignoring the normal timelines seems like good enough reason to play procedural hardball.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We don’t know what the Republicans will do next. The other day Senator Kennedy was suggesting they focus on Reconciliation bill instead of nominations. They can’t have both.
I really would prefer they stick to judges. We don’t need a trillion dollars for the Department of Defense.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Senate may soon be pressed to vote to fill several top DOJ positions that (what a shame) are currently vacant, according to a piece in Politico yesterday. Add that into the mix. Thune and company certainly have their work cut out for them in the remaining weeks of this Congress. They may have to work through the holidays or, horrors, pass up December fundraisers…
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s not gonna be a cake walk. You still have disaffected Republicans like Tillis and Cornyn. I also heard that Susan Collins is concerned!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would rather they focus on anything but judges shawnee.
We don’t need more unfit hacks being elevated.
I know we’re not going to stop all of them but we can try our best to drag it out so others don’t get confirmed.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I don’t say this to be snarky or anything, but if this ground stop continues through the weekend, it could impact who’s in DC to vote on judges on Monday.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Someone made a good point too, it’s pretty clear Fetterman is going to vote yes on any and all of the horrible nominees, so Republicans can afford to lose a couple of members and STILL have the votes for these judges.
Let’s hope there are more delays or bad weather so there are less in days for Senate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not sure I agree with that. On the last three votes taken this week on judicial nominations, Fetterman voted no on two, and did not vote on another. He’s been pretty good on judicial nominees, I’d be kinda shocked if he did a total 180 now. I don’t agree with a lot of the other positions he has taken recently; he has been a disappointment and I would not vote for him again.
I can see him going independent like Manchin or Sinema (caucus with Dems), but I’d be somewhat surprised if he became a Republican. He’s becoming irrelevant, and will be a one term senator.
I’m watching the T. Elliot Gaiser nomination, curious to see if Cornyn supports him, considering the WH rammed him down their throat. I think the clock has run on more nominees, but I wonder if Grassley gets rid of norms and processes late nominees anyway. Sets a horrible precedent, but Republicans just don’t seem to care. All things considered, limiting them to 14 circuit court nominees is pretty great.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Mike S. is correct that Fetterman has voted no on most Trump judicial nominees, but there hasn’t been a Trump judicial nominee in which Fetterman was the deciding vote, and we all know how Collins, Murkowski, Tillis, etc. have voted when they are the deciding vote.
That being said, Fetterman has ruined it for all of us who are pro-wearing shorts to work.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Ryan, I am a frequent wearer of Carhartt and black gym shorts, so the Fetterman heel turn has been devastating to me personally.
LikeLiked by 1 person
@Mike S, If Manchin/Sinema hadn’t done what they did towards the end, The Federalist Society would have had only 11 Circuit Court judges and no flips.
I will note while there aren’t many left, the remaining Reagan/George Sr Judges still in active service are all in their 70’s or even 80’s, with some Clinton judges like Robert King in the same boat.
If the worst happens, at least we don’t have to worry about younger hacks taking their seats for the Republican judges or flips with the moderate/liberal jurists.
One thing that I am grateful for under Biden, the 2nd Circuit would be a horror show right now if Trump had been in office back then.
LikeLiked by 2 people
My understanding is that by the end of 2028, there will be close to 50 circuit court judges eligible to assume senior status. Additionally, another 150 + district court judges will be eligible. Those are big numbers, and I am hopeful that we will have a Dem in the W.H. as well as a Dem Senate.
I would suggest working to get the JUDGEs Act passed in this upcoming Congress; if you have to split the 9th Circuit to do it, or name a federal court house after Trump somewhere in Alabama, then so be it. The next administration will have a huge opportunity to make an impact on the federal judiciary.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Senator Ashley Moody posted an update on lame duck judicial confirmations… The first paragraph reads…
“Our work through the holiday has resulted in Dems caving to expedited votes for constitutionalist judges for lifetime appointments today, with the final votes Monday after time under the rules runs over the weekend”…
I swear this better not be true
LikeLike
They allowed for two cloture votes on Thursday, with confirmation to follow this week coming up. They could have dragged out the votes over the weekend, with the exact same outcome. So really, it’s an optics thing.
I wish Dems would play hard ball, but the reality is two-fold: Republicans (by and large) have the votes to confirm most of these nominees, and Dems just don’t care about the judiciary as much as Reps do.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh ok. Two votes is a big difference from ALL pending nominees. Ok thanks for the explanation
LikeLike
What I can’t tell is what they’re doing today. From the executive calendar, it seems like they’re doing confirmation votes on St. John and Domenico, but not clear if they’re also doing cloture on the 4 district nominees
And, as expected, they’re rushing through the TX nominees before Talarico can take office. We should do a poll on how many vacancies we expect to be unfilled when this Congress ends.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cornyn is blocking Gaiser. I really hope he doesn’t fold:
https://www.rawstory.com/john-cornyn-2678420986/
LikeLiked by 2 people
Steve Fahey was born c. 1972. If I was Talarico, I would call Cornyn up & commit to turning in my blue slip next year for Fahey if Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, who is over a decade & a half younger & also one of Trump’s attorney’s who tried to overturn the 2020 election.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Demand Justice put out an ad urging Schumer not to confirm any Trump judges.
https://sg.news.yahoo.com/demand-justice-rips-chuck-schumer-222024220.html
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite frankly, it isn’t fair to the judicial system to put a complete halt on confirmations. That being said, there will need to be compromises and no more FedSoc hacks should be confirmed.
LikeLiked by 1 person